Milly Alcock's performance shines, but critics question the film's direction and script
Category: Arts & Culture
The highly anticipated film Supergirl, the second major release in James Gunn’s new DC Universe, has received a mixed response from critics following its early screenings. As of June 24, 2026, the film holds a fluctuating Rotten Tomatoes score of 61% to 62%, with reviews highlighting both strengths and weaknesses in its execution.
Directed by Craig Gillespie and featuring Milly Alcock as Kara Zor-El, Supergirl follows the titular character on an interstellar adventure filled with themes of revenge and personal discovery. Critics have praised Alcock’s performance, noting her ability to bring a fresh energy to the role, yet many have pointed out shortcomings in the film's script and character development.
As the critic embargo lifted, the initial Rotten Tomatoes score revealed a divided reception. Reviews range from commendations of Alcock’s portrayal to criticisms of the film’s narrative structure. At the time of writing, the score was reported at 61% based on 86 reviews, with a notable drop from earlier expectations that had placed it as high as 76% earlier in the month. This score indicates that the film is currently classified as ‘Fresh,’ though the mixed early reactions suggest it may not meet the high standards set by its predecessor, Superman, which holds an 83% rating.
Many critics have voiced their appreciation for Alcock’s performance. For example, a review from MovieWeb lauded her as “fantastic,” emphasizing that she embodies the character well. Alcock’s portrayal of a brash and often inebriated 22-year-old Supergirl has been described as a departure from traditional superhero narratives, presenting a character who grapples with her past and identity. Critics from Collider and Comic Basics echoed this sentiment, noting her ability to deliver a performance that resonates with audiences, even when the film around her falters.
Conversely, the film's script, penned by Ana Nogueira, has faced scrutiny. Reviewers have pointed out its inconsistent tonal balance, with some describing it as a “thin script” that struggles to fully capture the essence of Supergirl. Critics from outlets like Variety and HeyUGuys remarked on the film’s lack of a strong supporting cast and narrative depth, which detracts from the impact of Alcock’s performance. The reviews indicate a consensus that, though Alcock shines, the film fails to deliver a cohesive and engaging story.
Supergirl is based on the comic series Supergirl: Woman of Tomorrow by Tom King and Bilquis Evely, and it diverges from conventional superhero origin tales. Instead, it focuses on Kara as she travels across the galaxy, dealing with the loss of her home planet and her struggles with purpose. Critics have noted that this narrative approach allows for a more complex character study but also leaves room for confusion and a lack of clarity in the overarching plot.
The film’s director, Craig Gillespie, known for his work on I, Tonya and Lars and the Real Girl, has been tasked with balancing the film's darker themes alongside the lighter, more comedic elements that are typical of the DC Universe under Gunn’s creative direction. Some reviewers have suggested that this balancing act results in a film that feels disjointed and lacks a clear voice. The film has been compared to other sci-fi adventures, drawing parallels to Mad Max and Guardians of the Galaxy, but critics argue that it does not quite reach the heights of those films.
The mixed reception of Supergirl poses questions about the future direction of the DC Universe, especially as it follows closely on the heels of Superman. With the film set to release on June 26, 2026, its box office performance will be closely monitored. Early projections suggest it may open with around $50 million domestically, which, if achieved, would be a moderate success but may not meet the ambitious expectations set by previous entries in the franchise.
As the co-CEO of DC Studios, James Gunn faces the challenge of guiding this interconnected cinematic universe. The success of Supergirl could significantly impact future projects, including the upcoming Clayface film, which is slated for release later this year. Critics and fans alike are eager to see how this new iteration of Supergirl will fit into the larger narrative that Gunn is crafting.
In the meantime, the film’s reception indicates that the DC Universe remains a work in progress, with potential for both growth and missteps. As audiences prepare to view Supergirl, the ultimate verdict will depend on whether they connect with this new version of Kara Zor-El and her adventures across the cosmos. With Milly Alcock leading the charge, there is hope that this film will resonate with fans and pave the way for a successful future in the DC Universe.